豤§èé°è¨éè¨è§ééè°é¨§è§·èJ·K·¨¨¤è¨§è·¨§§èLGBTQ¤èé¤è·¨§èè§(Trans-Exclusionary Radical Feminists/ T.E.R.F.)èè°è°èéèé·¤èèè¨è¨¨è·±§è
è§èèè·¨§èè¤éé±éèè°èé±è±¤°é·èé¨èè°è·°è±·¤¤§¤·ééé§è¨èè±é
153èèè¨èèèA Letter on Justice and Open Debateè
èéééè餧豤èèèéè±èééèè¨èè·¨§§§§èè§è·èéè±èéèéé¤è駧±
¨è§è°èéé°è±èè·¨§§§¤§é¨èè§éèéè·¨§§§è¤é§
±éé°±èè°è±è§¨§°§è褰¤èèéè¨è¨·è§è§¤è¨è§èè°èèéè°·§è¨èè¤èè
1
褧·
°±§
éèè¨èè¨èèè°è
谧跨§§§·§§è¤§è·èèèèè§è·é¤J·K·èé§è·¨§èè§è¨è§èè°éèèè·¨§è§éèè觨è§è·è¨éè±é
è±è·¨§·§°Jammidodger°±°°éèè°··§Jammidodgerèè°è·¨§¤¤è¤è§·¨èè¨è§·¨è±°è±·§§é§è§§é觧èè§è¤è¨¨èéè
èè·±è¤è°é褰±è§§·§é訨è·è·¨§§§§è§¤§è·¨§§èèè¤è訷
é·¨
¨èè餧é褧·¨§è§·§§é¨°§è¨èè°°¤·èé°è°··èè§èèè¨è·èè°±§èè§è°èperformativeèè°èè
褧·¨§¤°è±§èéèè°¤èè褧·¨è§èè·è¤§·¨§¤°§°±éé觷
褰·°¤è·§·§è§è§è·§·±è°è¤èè··§è¨§·§é§·
訧·é§···é觷§è°§é§éèé§éè°¨§èé°¨°§éé
¨è·è§è¨è¨è§·§è¤¤è·éééè°è觧é餧
2
§è
èè·±
é谱餷°·èéè·¨¤è¤±·è·
¨°±èéè褨èé褧訤è¤è¤·é·¨è§·§è·§§
§è¨§è±°±°§°¤¤¤§·éèè觨é§éè¤è±èè±é§é¤·¤è§èèé·èèè¨è褷èèéè°èè¤èè·è§éè¤
°¨èéèèè°è騤¤°è¨èèèè¨è§§éè±é¨èè±è±¨··èéèèè¨è§·§±è±èé°è¤è§°§è·èéè§èè跱跨è·èè¤è°è±§¨è°è§é褨¤éè¤è¨éèè§è·±è
±¨··è
§èè§éé·§¤èèé·èè§éè¨èè§è¤§·é§±è
§§§è·±°è±¨èè§è°è§°è±è§§éè·§§¨èèè§è§·§§é§é§é¤
§éé褷餧¤§èèèè°±§§è¨è¤ééè¨èèèè°é·éé觤¤±§¨§·¤è¤§§§§
訧§§¨è§éé¨é¨ééé§è¨è§§é騤éè
訤¨·èè°è§è¨becoming§nomadè¨è·é¤èè·è¤¨é¤·°··è§é¤¤èè¤èèèè±°è¨è°°°éèè¤è
·°èè¨è
·±§§è褷§é°·°§è訨§§§¤§ééèéèè觰鷨éèé¨è±universalsè·¨§·°±é褨§é§è¤èè§é
觧·§¤§¨èè°¨¨èè餰éèé¤èè°±èè··étranscendental subjectè¤è§èé·é褱訰±è¤èè
é騤èè§è¨¤¨èè¨èè°è§èèèé¤é褷¤¤§èèèèè§èè¨é§¤§¤§°°¨è¤è¤èè¨èèé°±è¤è°éè¨èè§éèè°°é·°é觧訷·
§é§§¤éèè¤èèéè°·è°±°§°¤§¤¤éè駨谤éééèèè°±·è·èè¨èè·é¤§é¨
觧·§è訰°±¤èè§è·é褰¨°¤é§è§·è¨§·±
() éé¤è°è·è20151
§·§¤é§éèé·¤èè±è¨¨§·§è¨é°±è跷觤豧°±¨è°è§§¤§è餧·èèè±·§°··°
3
vs è§
¨è§
§¤è±éè°±·é§è¨§¤è±°±é¨¨è±§·§èè¤é¤§é
褧·§¤§¤§é¨°±°§èé駤豰§èèè§èè°è褧é§èè¨è·è訷è跰觰±ééé騧
¨§è¨§§èè§è駧觧豱¤°°è¤è¤°§è°è§±·¨è·éè¤èèè·ééèè¤é±è
è§èèéè褧跧°¤èèè訨¤è·±·èè·¤§èéèè·§°èé§è¤¤§§§è§
è°èèéèè¨é§è§§¤·éèé駷§°±èéé騤·§§èé褱
¨·Henri Bergson1927èè°èéèè
±§°è§è§§è°è褧§è¤°§è¨èè°±è§è§°§§è¨¤¤¤·§è¤¤§§è¤è§§è§§é觰±è§¨··è
§è駷è觧·§°·é°¤è¤§è¤èèé褧éé褧·§é¤éé騤èèè
éèè[] ¨·èèèèè¤20119
èè°è¤¤§¤èé°±é§è§§¤§§è觷ééè¨è·°¨èé¤è·èè騧·§¤§èèè§è§§èéè°±¨é觤§·§èè¤è·è¤è¤
¤§è§°±°¤éè±éè§èéè§éè訰èè§ééè§é餧è§é°é§equivalenceè§é§è¨·§difference
èé訧è±è¤¨èè§é¨èè°±¤·¨é¤§¤¤§è§èè°è§§èèéé觷§¤§é¤¤§éè°±è·è§§èèèè豤§è±°±è§é餤é·èè豨é
褧跧·§§è¤§éèè·é¨è§è¤é§é§é觧¤è·§¨è¤§¨è¤·°±¤è¨¤§è¨è±è¤°è
±èè2015§§
4
·è
¤§·¨¤è·±
è§èéè
é§è¤è±è駧¤·§è¤èèè§ééè¤
¨¨éé觤èè°è§¤§·§§è§è§è¨è§è§°¤è
¨§è餰觧褧¤§è§é¤°§é§¤°·è¤§§è§°èè觧·§èè§é¤èè§é¤è
§éè§é°±¤§¤èè§è·±è¤§èè·±°è·è§è¤§è·±é¤·èè觷éèè°·¨·èé谨豰
§·è¨è
±·è¤èèè騧訧·§é§·è觧éé··è·¤èé·¤§è·
è·è·è°·èèè餧è§è¨ééé§è¨¤¤éè餧·§·¨éè¨èè觤è§è訧èè§
èé·è觰°ééè±éé°2013§§°éèèèèè
éè
è·é¤J·K·èé
éè
éèèè°ééé