voltdb3.0和redis单节点的性能比对

目标 ：

在相同的硬件和软件环境下，比较voltdb3.0和redis存取的性能。

硬件环境：

800M内存，单核。

软件环境：

CentOS6.0 64位。

Voltdb：

运行voltdb中自带的例子程序voltkv来得到其性能数据。

redis：

运行redis中对应的benchmark来获取其性能数据。

voltdb性能测试结果：

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Command Line Configuration
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

autotune = true
displayinterval = 5
duration = 120
entropy = 127
getputratio = 0.9
keysize = 32
latencytarget = 6
maxvaluesize = 1024
minvaluesize = 1024
poolsize = 100000
preload = true
ratelimit = 100000
servers = localhost
statsfile =
usecompression = false
warmup = 5

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Setup & Initialization
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Connecting to VoltDB...
Connected to VoltDB node at: localhost.

Preloading data store...
Preloading complete.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Starting Benchmark
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Warming up...

Running benchmark...
00:00:05 Throughput 9540/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 23.07/65ms
00:00:10 Throughput 10727/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 15.71/32ms
00:00:15 Throughput 9664/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 21.36/45ms
00:00:20 Throughput 9232/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 16.12/32ms
00:00:25 Throughput 8876/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 28.18/75ms
00:00:30 Throughput 12220/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 15.83/31ms
00:00:35 Throughput 10703/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 17.90/35ms
00:00:40 Throughput 11577/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 16.75/32ms
00:00:45 Throughput 10844/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 18.52/33ms
00:00:50 Throughput 11323/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 16.32/32ms
00:00:55 Throughput 10703/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 17.88/29ms
00:01:00 Throughput 12348/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 15.42/31ms
00:01:05 Throughput 12166/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 14.90/31ms
00:01:10 Throughput 10981/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 19.38/34ms
00:01:15 Throughput 11377/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 16.64/36ms
00:01:20 Throughput 10844/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 18.71/30ms
00:01:25 Throughput 13214/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 11.79/28ms
00:01:30 Throughput 9920/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 19.10/36ms
00:01:35 Throughput 9042/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 18.03/38ms
00:01:40 Throughput 11839/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 13.35/27ms
00:01:45 Throughput 7761/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 20.93/40ms
00:01:50 Throughput 11768/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 13.88/34ms
00:01:55 Throughput 11363/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 14.55/35ms
00:02:00 Throughput 10685/s, Aborts/Failures 0/0, Avg/95% Latency 20.81/35ms

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 KV Store Results
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

A total of 1,293,752 operations were posted...
 - GETs: 1,163,698 Operations (0 Misses and 0 Failures)
             1,136 MB in compressed store data
             1,136 MB in uncompressed application data
         Network Throughput:  0.076 Gbps*
 - PUTs:   129,786 Operations (0 Failures)
               126 MB in compressed store data
               126 MB in uncompressed application data
         Network Throughput:  0.074 Gbps*
 - Total Network Throughput:  0.151 Gbps*

* Figure includes key & value traffic but not database protocol overhead.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Client Workload Statistics
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Average throughput:               10,779 txns/sec
Average latency:                   17.42 ms
95th percentile latency:              35 ms
99th percentile latency:              55 ms

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 System Server Statistics
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Targeted Internal Avg Latency:         6 ms
Reported Internal Avg Latency:      6.18 ms

 

redis性能测试结果：

====== PING (inline) ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.48 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

42.90% <= 1 milliseconds

 

85.71% <= 2 milliseconds

 

98.92% <= 3 milliseconds

 

99.82% <= 4 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 4 milliseconds

 

20964.36 requests per second

 

 

 

====== PING ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.47 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

42.76% <= 1 milliseconds

 

86.97% <= 2 milliseconds

 

99.40% <= 3 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 3 milliseconds

 

21231.42 requests per second

 

 

 

====== MSET (10 keys) ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.59 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

35.67% <= 1 milliseconds

 

71.49% <= 2 milliseconds

 

96.71% <= 3 milliseconds

 

99.15% <= 4 milliseconds

 

99.34% <= 5 milliseconds

 

99.53% <= 6 milliseconds

 

99.66% <= 20 milliseconds

 

99.82% <= 21 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 21 milliseconds

 

17035.78 requests per second

 

 

 

====== SET ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.50 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

40.50% <= 1 milliseconds

 

81.33% <= 2 milliseconds

 

98.45% <= 3 milliseconds

 

99.85% <= 4 milliseconds

 

99.99% <= 5 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 5 milliseconds

 

20000.00 requests per second

 

 

 

====== GET ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.49 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

41.81% <= 1 milliseconds

 

84.55% <= 2 milliseconds

 

98.77% <= 3 milliseconds

 

99.75% <= 4 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 4 milliseconds

 

20449.90 requests per second

 

 

 

====== INCR ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.49 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

42.31% <= 1 milliseconds

 

84.51% <= 2 milliseconds

 

98.72% <= 3 milliseconds

 

99.77% <= 4 milliseconds

 

99.97% <= 5 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 5 milliseconds

 

20576.13 requests per second

 

 

 

====== LPUSH ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.48 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

41.35% <= 1 milliseconds

 

83.84% <= 2 milliseconds

 

98.90% <= 3 milliseconds

 

99.62% <= 4 milliseconds

 

99.73% <= 5 milliseconds

 

99.80% <= 6 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 6 milliseconds

 

20703.93 requests per second

 

 

 

====== LPOP ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.49 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

41.39% <= 1 milliseconds

 

84.15% <= 2 milliseconds

 

98.48% <= 3 milliseconds

 

99.68% <= 4 milliseconds

 

99.89% <= 5 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 5 milliseconds

 

20325.20 requests per second

 

 

 

====== SADD ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.49 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

41.14% <= 1 milliseconds

 

83.54% <= 2 milliseconds

 

98.80% <= 3 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 4 milliseconds

 

20618.56 requests per second

 

 

 

====== SPOP ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.48 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

42.22% <= 1 milliseconds

 

85.33% <= 2 milliseconds

 

99.03% <= 3 milliseconds

 

99.76% <= 4 milliseconds

 

99.82% <= 5 milliseconds

 

99.85% <= 6 milliseconds

 

99.97% <= 7 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 7 milliseconds

 

20661.16 requests per second

 

 

 

====== LPUSH (again, in order to bench LRANGE) ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.50 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

41.27% <= 1 milliseconds

 

82.52% <= 2 milliseconds

 

98.45% <= 3 milliseconds

 

99.43% <= 4 milliseconds

 

99.88% <= 5 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 5 milliseconds

 

20000.00 requests per second

 

 

 

====== LRANGE (first 100 elements) ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.60 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

33.77% <= 1 milliseconds

 

68.06% <= 2 milliseconds

 

95.98% <= 3 milliseconds

 

99.84% <= 4 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 5 milliseconds

 

16722.41 requests per second

 

 

 

====== LRANGE (first 300 elements) ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 0.95 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

24.73% <= 1 milliseconds

 

51.01% <= 2 milliseconds

 

75.01% <= 3 milliseconds

 

94.82% <= 4 milliseconds

 

99.13% <= 5 milliseconds

 

99.75% <= 6 milliseconds

 

99.92% <= 7 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 8 milliseconds

 

10570.83 requests per second

 

 

 

====== LRANGE (first 450 elements) ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 1.12 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

20.74% <= 1 milliseconds

 

42.82% <= 2 milliseconds

 

64.65% <= 3 milliseconds

 

83.92% <= 4 milliseconds

 

97.35% <= 5 milliseconds

 

99.59% <= 6 milliseconds

 

99.96% <= 7 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 7 milliseconds

 

8896.80 requests per second

 

 

 

====== LRANGE (first 600 elements) ======

 

  10000 requests completed in 1.26 seconds

 

  50 parallel clients

 

  3 bytes payload

 

  keep alive: 1

 

 

 

17.90% <= 1 milliseconds

 

37.25% <= 2 milliseconds

 

57.29% <= 3 milliseconds

 

75.23% <= 4 milliseconds

 

91.51% <= 5 milliseconds

 

98.24% <= 6 milliseconds

 

99.34% <= 7 milliseconds

 

99.64% <= 8 milliseconds

 

99.80% <= 9 milliseconds

 

99.88% <= 10 milliseconds

 

99.99% <= 11 milliseconds

 

100.00% <= 11 milliseconds

 

7942.81 requests per second