Pending Problem
这个问题发生在今年的1月，用户以操作系统认证形式登陆RAC中的主用实例时发现登陆挂起，但不出现错误。之后应用人员陆续手动杀死服务进程，杀死进程后发现实例可以登录了，应用人员在没有做任何信息转储的情况下重启了数据库，这就造成了我们后期诊断时缺乏必要的信息，也是这个case变成悬案的主要原因。 在实例hang住的一个半小时中告警日志没有任何信息；仅有的有用信息是该实例中diag，pmon，lmd后台进程的trace文件。以下为trace文件:
lmd0 trace:
*** 2010-01-16 11:02:58.106
DUMP LOCAL BLOCKER/HOLDER: block level 5 res [0x10b0005][0xeb5],[TX]
----------resource 0x70000044a76e1a0----------------------
resname : [0x10b0005][0xeb5],[TX]
Local node : 1
dir_node : 1
master_node : 1
hv idx : 25
hv last r.inc : 0
current inc : 20
hv status : 0
hv master : 0
open options : dd
grant_bits : KJUSERNL KJUSEREX
grant mode : KJUSERNL KJUSERCR KJUSERCW KJUSERPR KJUSERPW KJUSEREX
count : 1 0 0 0 0 1
val_state : KJUSERVS_NOVALUE
valblk : 0x00000000000000000000000000000000 .
access_node : 1
vbreq_state : 0
state : x0
resp : 70000044a76e1a0
On Scan_q? : N
Total accesses: 15061
Imm. accesses: 12545
Granted_locks : 1
Cvting_locks : 1
value_block: 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00
GRANTED_Q :
lp 700000488546990 gl KJUSEREX rp 70000044a76e1a0 [0x10b0005][0xeb5],[TX]
master 1 gl owner 70000048dd08220 possible pid 2928930 xid 2033-0333-0026D22C bast 0 rseq 215 mseq 0 history 0x14951495
open opt KJUSERDEADLOCK
CONVERT_Q:
lp 700000488546ae0 gl KJUSERNL rl KJUSEREX rp 70000044a76e1a0 [0x10b0005][0xeb5],[TX]
master 1 gl owner 70000048ee0ed48 possible pid 2040272 xid 2006-0066-0006F888 bast 0 rseq 215 mseq 0 history 0x1495149a
convert opt KJUSERGETVALUE KJUSERTRCCANCEL
----------enqueue 0x700000488546990------------------------
lock version : 2242641
Owner node : 1
grant_level : KJUSEREX
req_level : KJUSEREX
bast_level : KJUSERNL
notify_func : 0
resp : 70000044a76e1a0
procp : 70000048928b8f0
pid : 2040272
proc version : 40135
oprocp : 0
opid : 0
group lock owner : 70000048dd08220
possible pid : 2928930
xid : 2033-0333-0026D22C
dd_time : 0.0 secs
dd_count : 0
timeout : 0.0 secs
On_timer_q? : N
On_dd_q? : N
lock_state : GRANTED
Open Options : KJUSERDEADLOCK
Convert options : KJUSERNOQUEUE
History : 0x14951495
Msg_Seq : 0x0
res_seq : 215
valblk : 0x00000000000000000000000000000000 .
DUMP LOCAL BLOCKER: initiate state dump for TIMEOUT
possible owner[819.2928930] on resource TX-010B0005-00000EB5
Submitting asynchronized dump request [28]
pmon trace:
*** SESSION ID:(3384.1) 2010-01-16 11:00:11.349
[claim lock for dead process][lp 0x7000004870f7078][p 0x7000004891a79e0.2928930][hist x49514951]
[claim lock for dead process][lp 0x700000488546990][p 0x70000048928b8f0.0][hist x49514951] <<<< note:this message@2010-01-16 12:35
pmon trace:
*** 2010-01-16 11:02:58.244
Dump requested by process [orapid=6]
REQUEST:custom dump [2] with parameters [6][819][2][2]
. process info of pid[819.2928930] requested by pid[6.3621092]
Dumping process 819.2928930 info:
*** 2010-01-16 11:02:58.244
Dumping diagnostic information for ospid 2928930:
OS pid = 2928930
loadavg : 10.83 10.96 10.91
swap info: free_mem = 21646.73M rsv = 128.00M
alloc = 235.52M avail = 32768.00M swap_free = 32532.48M
F S UID PID PPID C PRI NI ADDR SZ WCHAN STIME TTY TIME CMD
240001 A orauser 2928930 1 120 120 20 6da7bd510 174068 10:35:28 - 1:50 oracleCRMDB22 (LOCAL=NO)
open: The file access permissions do not allow the specified action.
procstack: write(/proc/2928930/ctl): The requested resource is busy.
2928930: oracleCRMDB22 (LOCAL=NO) lmd0进程的trace文件显示该进程发现了本地存在阻塞超时的问题，[0x10b0005][0xeb5],[TX]资源的拥有者是2928930进程，而pmon进程认为2928930进程可能出于僵死状态，故希望RAC中的diag进程能对该进程做进一步的诊断，diag进程受到pmon的邀请"Dump requested by process [orapid=6]",尝试"Dumping process 819.2928930 info:"，并利用AIX上的procstack调试工具分析此进程当时的调用栈，但出现了"procstack: write(/proc/2928930/ctl): The requested resource is busy"的错误，在网上搜索该记录的相关信息发现可能是AIX上procstack工具的一个Bug，而跟实例挂起问题关系不大:
Problem summary **************************************************************** * USERS AFFECTED: * Users of the procstac command on the 5300-09 Technology Level * with the bos.perf.proctools fileset at the 5.3.9.0 and 5.3.9.1 * levels. **************************************************************** * PROBLEM DESCRIPTION: * The procstac command fails with an error similar to: * * open: Permission denied * procstack: write(/proc/2068724/ctl): Device busy **************************************************************** * RECOMMENDATION: * Install APAR IZ47903. **************************************************************** Problem conclusion *Modified the code to fix this problelm.diag进程的跟踪文件还显示2928930进程持有redo copy latch；这个case发生后的一个礼拜恰好有Oracle原厂工程师到该客户单位做巡检，原厂工程师查看了实例挂起期间的ASH报告，发现该时段内实例中redo相关的等待频繁发生，基本可以认定是僵死进程持有"redo copy latch"造成了RAC中单实例hang住。 原厂工程师的结论令客户比较满意，这个case基本可以结束了。但我对这个结论并不完全认同，2928930进程持有的redo copy latch是一个子栓，该类子栓在实例上的总数取决于CPU总数，一般来说等于CPU * 2；该实例所在服务器为IBM的p595配有32个cpu，redo copy latch共有64个，单单一个子栓被hold住会造成整个实例都hang住，且登录挂起吗？
SQL> show parameter cpu_count
NAME TYPE VALUE
------------------------------------ ----------- ------------------------------
cpu_count integer 32
SQL> select count(*) from v$latch_children where name='redo copy';
COUNT(*)
----------
64
/*我们在非生产环境测试一下*/
select addr "十六进制地址",
to_number(addr, 'xxxxxxxxxxxx') "十进制地址",
gets,
misses,
immediate_gets,
immediate_misses
from v$latch_children
where name = 'redo copy';
十六进制 十进制地址 GETS MISSES IMMEDIATE_GETS IMMEDIATE_MISSES
-------- ---------- ---------- ---------- -------------- ----------------
2DAB5898 766204056 7 0 0 0
2DAB5818 766203928 5 0 0 0
2DAB5798 766203800 5 0 0 0
2DAB5718 766203672 5 0 0 0
2DAB5698 766203544 5 0 0 0
2DAB5618 766203416 5 0 0 0
2DAB5598 766203288 5 0 511 0
2DAB5518 766203160 5 0 297024 347
8 rows selected.
/*正式测试前的redo copy child latch统计信息，我们还要用到这里的十进制latch地址*/
/*我们尝试手动hold住一个redo copy child latch，并在其他会话中执行一些产生redo的操作*/
session A:
SQL> oradebug setmypid;
Statement processed.
SQL> oradebug call kslgetl 766203160 1;
Function returned 1
/* kslgetl是Oracle内部用get latch的函数，oradebug 可以调用该函数*/
session B:
SQL> select * From v$latchholder;
PID SID LADDR NAME GETS
---------- ---------- -------- ---------------------------------------------------------------- ----------
22 136 2DAB5518 redo copy 297443
另外开三个session,执行一下批量插入数据的匿名块，测试redo是否能够正常产生：
begin
for i in 1 .. 90000 loop
insert into tv values (i, i, i);
commit;
end loop;
end;
/
PL/SQL procedure successfully completed.
session A:
SQL> oradebug call kslfre 766203160 1;
Function returned 2FD548E0
/*手动释放766203160对应的redo copy 子闩*/
select addr "十六进制地址",
to_number(addr, 'xxxxxxxxxxxx') "十进制地址",
gets,
misses,
immediate_gets,
immediate_misses
from v$latch_children
where name = 'redo copy';
十六进制 十进制地址 GETS MISSES IMMEDIATE_GETS IMMEDIATE_MISSES
-------- ---------- ---------- ---------- -------------- ----------------
2DAB5898 766204056 7 0 0 0
2DAB5818 766203928 5 0 0 0
2DAB5798 766203800 5 0 0 0
2DAB5718 766203672 5 0 745 0
2DAB5698 766203544 5 0 122370 5
2DAB5618 766203416 5 0 176712 5
2DAB5598 766203288 5 0 144441 6
2DAB5518 766203160 6 0 297443 373
/*可以看到虽然8个子闩中一个被手动hold住，但对实例的影响远不足以到达hang所需要的条件*/ 虽然能证明单个redo copy latch被僵死进程长期持有和实例hang住没有必然的因果联系，但因为缺少相关的systemstate和hanganalyze转储信息，我们也无法进一步做出推断。 这个case发生后的几个月，我无意中在MOS上发现了以下Bug note:
Diagnostic collection may hang or crash the instance Description Sometimes while the DIAG process is collecting diagnostics the database may hang or crash. This is more likely to occur in a RAC or ASM environment . You may be seeing this problem if the database crashes or hangs just after you see the following text in a trace file: "Dumping diagnostic information for X" where X is the process that hung or terminated. This fix replaces invokations of a port specific OS debugger (like gdb) with Oracle ORADEBUG calls to gather the required diagnostics. Note: For HP Itanium fixes for this issue in 10.2.0.3/10.2.0.4 use bug 8767023 instead of this bug#. For AIX fixes for this issue in 10.2.0.3/10.2.0.4 use bug 8929701 instead of this bug#. Workaround >=10.2.0.3 only: Set init.ora parameter "_ksb_disable_diagpid" = TRUE but this will disable automatic diagnostics collection.当diag诊断进程调用系统debugger工具调试问题进程时可能出现实例hang或crash的，且该问题多发于RAC或ASM环境中，workaroud的方法是动态设置_ksb_disable_diagpid为TRUE，可以避免diag诊断进程对问题进程的调试，但这些调试信息往往对我们又是有用的，这倒有些《种树郭橐驼说》中"既然已，勿动勿虑，去不复顾"的味道。 好了这个问题，仍旧pending着，是个悬案。