接入苹果支付（Sign In With Apple）后遇到的被拒审的坑

背景呢：就是新提交的APP，如果接入第三方登录，就得接入苹果登录。直接开始介绍趟坑的经过

第一版：

开始接入：大概的登录设计是下面这样的

image.png

先贴下被拒邮件：

被拒邮件1

Guideline 4.0 - Design

Your app uses Sign in with Apple as a login option but does not use the appropriate Sign in with Apple button design, branding, and/or user interface elements as described in the Sign in With Apple Human Interface Guidelines. Specifically:

• The custom Sign in with Apple button in your app.
  Next Steps
  To resolve this issue, revise the Sign in with Apple button design, branding and/or user interface elements in your app so that it follows all the Sign in With Apple Human Interface Guidelines.
  Resources
  For information on implementing Sign in with Apple in your app:
• Review Sign in with Apple Buttons Overview for specific guidance on button design
• Review Displaying Sign in with Apple Buttons if your sign in process happens in a browser
• Review the Sign in with Apple Human Interface Guidelines for an overview of design and formatting guidelines for Sign in with Apple

被拒邮件2:同1

被拒邮件3:

Guideline 5.1.1 - Legal - Privacy - Data Collection and Storage
We noticed that your app requires users to register with personal information that is not directly relevant to your app’s core functionality. Specifically, the following fields or actions are required but do not appear to be directly relevant to your app’s core functionality:

• Your app requires two-factor authentication after users login with Sign in with Apple.
  Next Steps
  To resolve this issue, please either remove all required fields that are not relevant to the app or make those fields optional. Information requested during registration must be relevant to the features the app provides.
  Additionally, make sure your app does not require two-factor authentication after users use Sign in with Apple. Sign in with Apple is a self-contained, all-in-one login system that should not require additional steps or information from the user.

被拒情况整理

被拒时间	拒审邮件	拒审截图	拒审问题分析	修改方案	审核结果
2020年8月19日 上午6:39	被拒邮件1	image.png	苹果登录设计没有遵守苹果规范，截图中着重标明的是文案，对文案进行修改。	将“Apple登录”文案替换为“Apple”，并将微信登录，QQ登录同样替换为微信，QQ	同样问题被拒审
2020年8月20日 上午10:29	被拒邮件2	image.png	苹果登录设计没有遵守苹果规范。	1、对第三方登录（Apple 微信 QQ）的文案进行全部移除。2、因为APP登录页面背景是明亮色，所以苹果登录按钮替换成黑色背景按钮	苹果登录设计规范过审
2020年8月20日 下午10:21	被拒邮件3	image.png	苹果登录后不允许进行手机号的强制绑定操作	针对apple登录/注册取消双重认证（绑定手机号的流程），针对QQ和微信登录/注册维持原有绑定手机号的流程	最终过审